
Quality and price are both spot on.

Winner
The Eastman Spruce/Maple A-Style Mandolin is a full-size instrument that could be a great choice for beginners looking for quality and traditional craftsmanship. It features a spruce top paired with a maple and ebony back, which typically offers a bright, clear tone that many players appreciate. The use of alloy steel strings is standard and durable for new players. The neck and fingerboard materials (maple and ebony) suggest good playability and a smooth feel, which is important when you are just starting to learn finger positions.
Its tuning machines are manual and well-made, which should help keep the instrument in tune without being too complicated for a beginner to handle. At nearly 7 pounds, it’s a bit on the heavier side, so some players might find it a little bulky at first. The sound is expected to be rich and balanced due to the high-quality wood choices, encouraging practice and progress for a first instrument.
One minor drawback is that it’s not among the most affordable beginner mandolins. Given Eastman’s reputation, this mandolin is likely a reliable and well-crafted instrument that can serve beginners well as they develop their skills.
The Eastman Guitars MD615 F-style Mandolin is a well-crafted instrument that beginners might find appealing due to its quality materials and classic design. It features a solid maple body and back combined with a spruce top, which generally produce a bright and clear sound—helping new players hear their notes distinctly. This model includes alloy steel strings, which are standard and easy to replace, along with tuning machines designed for stable tuning, essential for those still developing their tuning skills.
The mandolin is an acoustic-electric model, offering flexibility to play unplugged or amplified, which can be a bonus for learners who want to explore different settings. Weighing over 8 pounds, it may feel a bit heavy for younger or smaller beginners, so trying its comfort and weight in person might be advisable.
This mandolin is a solid choice for beginners looking for a quality instrument that can grow with their skills.
The Kentucky KM-156 is a solid choice for beginners looking for a quality A-model mandolin. Its body features a solid carved spruce top and maple back and sides, which together create a bright, crisp tone with good projection—ideal for clear sound whether playing solo or with others. The slim maple neck and East Indian rosewood fingerboard make it comfortable to hold and play, especially for newcomers who might be adjusting to finger placement and string tension.
The tuning machines are reliable, helping the instrument stay in tune during practice or performance. Its action (the distance between strings and fingerboard) is set up for smooth playability, easing the learning curve. The transparent brown lacquer finish not only looks elegant but also preserves the wood's natural resonance. Weighing just under 3 pounds, it’s light enough to handle without strain.
Beginners who want a dependable, well-made mandolin with good tone and playability will find this model a strong start without overwhelming complexity.